There are only six verses in Psalm 23, yet few passages of Scripture have shaped the Church as deeply. It is one of the most memorized, prayed, and cherished portions of the Bible. And it has been that way for generations. For many of us, it is among the first passages we learn by heart. Its simplicity makes it memorable, but its depth makes it inexhaustible, as Gibson writes, “The riches in this psalm are inexhaustible.”
Psalm 23 is what I like to call portable theology. It is a poem for the pilgrimage. It is a confession that is meant to travel with us. It is a song that reminds us who our Shepherd is and teaches us how to interpret every season of life through God’s character. God’s character is active, caring, and intimate. As Gibson writes, “From start to end, the language describing God is active, intensive, causative—he makes, he leads, he restores, he leads again, he is with me, he prepares, he anoints.”
Written by David, a shepherd who later became Israel’s king, Psalm 23 reflects both personal experience and Israel’s story. David knew what it meant to lead sheep. He also knew what it meant to be pursued, threatened, and sustained by God’s faithfulness. As a student of Israel’s history, he understood the wilderness, exile, and God’s covenant care. In these six verses, we encounter a God who nourishes, protects, guides, welcomes, and remains present with the people of God.
Recently, I had the opportunity to read The Lord of Psalm 23 by David Gibson, provided by Crossway. On their website, Crossway accurately describes this book as an “Expository Study of Psalm 23 Reveals the Beauty and Deep Theological Meaning behind a Familiar Part of Scripture.” Although the book was first published in 2023, I read the 2026 Crossway edition. I was not familiar with the earlier addition. However, after having recently preached through Psalm 23, I found myself wishing I had read this book beforehand.
A Window into the Whole Story of Scripture
Gibson’s central argument is that Psalm 23 reveals God as Shepherd, Companion, and Host. Even more importantly, the same God we meet in Psalm 23 is the God revealed fully in Jesus Christ. The Shepherd of David’s song is the Shepherd we encounter in Jesus’ life, ministry, death, and resurrection.
As Gibson writes, the riches of Psalm 23 are inexhaustible. These six verses function almost like a window into the entire story of Scripture. They lead us through creation, redemption, wilderness, restoration, and ultimately into the hope of God’s eternal presence.
Psalm 23 is both majestic and intensely personal. We confess who our Shepherd is, but we also discover where He is. He walks before us, leading. He walks beside us, comforting. He stands behind us with goodness and mercy. He protects us even in the darkest valleys.
This Shepherd we confess doesn’t need us, he loves us out of his goodness. Gibson remarks about his soverignity in this way, God’s “existence is from himself and for himself, and there is nothing about him that is derived in any way from anyone else. God is absolutely self-sufficient self-existence, and he is your shepherd.” As a result, this psalm reminds us who is our shepherd. That Shepherd, “the one whom you need to shepherd you neither needs you nor needs to be shepherded himself as he gives himself to shepherd you. He shepherds you from his eternally undiminishing fullness, and he is never the poorer for it.”
The Structure of the Book
Gibson organizes the book into three major sections that follow the movement of Psalm 23. In Psalm 23, as Dr. David Gibson shares, we are given “a window into the sixty-six books os Scripture, and [it takes] us through the whole story of redemption in an elevated, majestic, and also personal, intimate way.” By breaking up the book into these three parts, we begin to recognize that reality. The first part is the Sheep and the Shepherd. Then the second part is The Traveler and the Companion. Lastly, the book looks at the third part, The Guest and the Host.
Part One: The Sheep and the Shepherd
The opening section explores the Shepherd’s identity. Gibson asks, “Who is the Lord we are confessing?” He then explores what this Shepherd provides—rest, nourishment, protection, compassion, and care. He also examines where the Shepherd leads His people and why His guidance matters.
Part Two: The Traveler and the Companion
The second section shifts to the journey itself. Gibson explores how shepherds actually lead sheep, examining the tools and practices behind the biblical imagery.
These chapters are particularly helpful because they ground the familiar language of Psalm 23 in the realities of ancient shepherding. Rather than treating the metaphors as sentimental, Gibson shows how they communicate God’s active presence, guidance, discipline, and protection.
Perhaps most importantly, this section reminds us that God is not waiting at the destination. God is with us on the journey.
Part Three: The Guest and the Host
The final section focuses on the banquet imagery that closes the psalm.
Here, Gibson explores God’s hospitality, God’s welcome, and God’s invitation into covenant fellowship. The table prepared before us is not merely a future promise—it is a present declaration of God’s favor and care.
Throughout this section, we are reminded that Psalm 23 continually calls us back to trust God’s character, receive God’s hospitality, and live transformed lives as those welcomed into His household.
Time and time again we find the character, will, and call of God on display through this memorable psalm. This is why it becomes portable theology.
Does the Book Accomplish Its Goal?
I believe The Lord of Psalm 23 succeeds in exactly what it sets out to do. Gibson gives readers an honest, careful reading of Psalm 23 while consistently showing how the psalm finds its fulfillment in Jesus Christ and the larger story of Scripture. Rather than treating Psalm 23 as an isolated devotional passage, he demonstrates how these six verses echo throughout the biblical narrative and ultimately point us to Christ.
This is a book that will earn a permanent place on my shelf. It is one I expect to return to often, especially as I prepare to preach or teach Psalm 23. It is also a book I will gladly recommend—not only to pastors but to anyone who wants to explore the depth and richness of one of the Bible’s best-loved psalms.
My only real critique comes in the opening chapters. Early on, Gibson spends considerable time connecting Psalm 23 to historic confessions, particularly the Heidelberg Catechism. I should note that this is not a criticism of the confessions themselves. Readers from a more Reformed tradition will likely find those connections both meaningful and essential. Personally, I tend to be less confessional, I am not Reforemd, and I lean more focused on the biblical text itself, so I found myself wanting more engagement with the psalm’s historical setting and imagery from the outset. Thankfully, as the book goes on, Gibson quickly broadens his approach, and the remainder of the book richly explores the biblical, theological, and cultural dimensions of Psalm 23.
One of Gibson’s strongest contributions is his reminder that modern life has distanced us from the world that produced this psalm. Technology, urban living, and the comforts of modern society have dulled our appreciation for the natural imagery that fills Psalm 23. He helps readers recover that world so the psalm can be heard as its first audience would have heard it.
One illustration that particularly stayed with me comes from Gibson’s discussion of the opening verses. Reflecting on the green pastures and still waters, he writes, about the abudnance of food in green pastures, the drink in the still waters, and the ability to rest even when we don’t know we need it. All the sheep’s needs are met in abundance.
Gibson’s observation captures something essential about the Shepherd’s care. The sheep do not need to wander elsewhere in search of something better because the Shepherd has already led them to a place of abundance. There is enough food. There is enough water. There is enough rest. It is in that place of security and contentment that the soul is restored.
That image reaches beyond the sheep to our own lives. When we remain with the Shepherd, we discover that God is enough. God’s presence restores not only our souls but every part of our lives. Our relationships, our anxieties, our work, and our worship are all shaped by learning to trust that the place where the Shepherd leads is ultimately the place of true abundance.
Seeing Psalm 23 Through the Story of Scripture
Beyond the book’s broader theological argument, one of its strongest contributions is the way Gibson traces Psalm 23 through the story of God’s people. Rather than treating the psalm as an isolated poem, he demonstrates that David intentionally draws on words, images, and themes from Israel’s history to remind God’s people of His covenant faithfulness.
First, when David declares, “I shall not want” (Psalm 23:1), Gibson connects that confession to Deuteronomy, where Israel is reminded that throughout the wilderness they “lacked nothing” because of God’s faithful provision. David is not merely expressing personal contentment; he is echoing Israel’s testimony that God has always been enough for His people.
Second, Gibson argues that the imagery of green pastures recalls the song of Moses in Exodus 15. The language of God’s pasture and the verb “to lead” appear there as God delivers Israel from Egypt and guides them toward the land He has promised. The Exodus was never simply about escape from slavery—it was about a Shepherd leading His people into a place of abundance, security, and covenant blessing.
Third, the “still waters” of Psalm 23:2 carry rich biblical echoes. Gibson notes that the language of resting places appears throughout the Old Testament, including Numbers 10, Genesis 2, and Deuteronomy 12. These resting places are not simply quiet locations but signs of God’s presence, provision, and covenant inheritance.
Finally, Gibson observes that David’s statement that God leads us “for his name’s sake” ties Psalm 23 back to the Exodus narrative. Throughout the Old Testament, God repeatedly acts for the sake of His own name. His guidance is rooted in His covenant faithfulness and His mission in the world. That does not diminish His care for us; rather, it assures us that His goodness toward His people flows from His unchanging character. The Shepherd leads because He is committed to glorifying His name, and that commitment is always for the good of those He loves.
Gibson explores each of these connections in far greater depth than I can summarize here, but this section was one of the highlights of the book for me. It helped me see that Psalm 23 is not simply a comforting psalm—it is a theological confession rooted in the entire story of God’s redeeming work.
More Than a Funeral Psalm
One of Gibson’s strongest emphases is that Psalm 23 is not primarily about death. Sadly, we have domesticated the Psalm’s use to funerals and gravesides.
Death casts its shadow across the psalm, but it is not the focus. Gibson reminds us that it is, in fact, a song for everyday life. He says, “Psalm 23 is about abundant life. It is more about the happiness of living than the sadness of dying, and all of the happiness is bound up with being able to say that this Lord who is a shepherd is also my shepherd.” It teaches us how to live before it teaches us how to die.
That is an important correction.
Final Thoughts on The Lord of Psalm 23
I highly recommend The Lord of Psalm 23. David Gibson carefully unpacks each of the six lines of this remarkable psalm, showing how they reveal God’s character, point us to Jesus, and connect to the larger story of Scripture.
Psalm 23 is more than comforting poetry. It is a theological confession designed to reshape our imagination. It is portable theology that accompanies us through every season of life. It confronts our anxiety with God’s presence, our fear with His protection, and our striving with His provision.
Like a song that stays with you long after the music ends, Psalm 23 is meant to become the soundtrack of the Christian life. Gibson’s book helps us hear that song more clearly.
Recommending The Lord of Pslam 23
If you’re looking for a light devotional on Psalm 23, this is probably not the book you’re after. But if you’re looking for a thoughtful theological exploration that remains deeply pastoral and consistently points you to Christ, The Lord of Psalm 23 is well worth reading. It has earned a permanent place on my shelf, and I expect to return to it often. I also encourage you to buy The Lord of Psalm 23 from Crossway.
You can also read some more of my thoughts on Psalm 23 on the Lead a Quiet Life Blog on Patheos, or this sermon from River Corner Church. Read my favorite quotes and highlights from the book here.
If this post resonated, subscribe for future reflections, share it with a friend, or leave a comment. You can learn more about his journey to recover a rooted Christian way of life through the Lord’s Prayer, ancient habits, leading a quiet life, and simple Jesus communities online at JeffMcLain.com, the Lead a Quiet Life blog on Patheos, or the Discovering God Podcast.
Discover more from Jeff McLain
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
